top of page
Writer's pictureGiovanni

Who put the Nog in my Eggnog?

Updated: Apr 23

Buckle up, folks! Have you ever found yourself cradling a frothy cup of eggnog, staring deep into its creamy depths, and asking the big questions? No, not the meaning of life or why your in-laws insist on visiting every holiday season. The real question here is: where on earth did the name 'eggnog' come from?

A festive mug of eggnog, symbolizing the history and holiday tradition of this creamy drink, sits on a table near a cozy hearth adorned with seasonal decorations

Don't worry, you're not alone, and lucky for you, we are bringing you along on a journey to uncover the etymology of 'nog' in eggnog.

This is your chance to embrace the holiday spirit, dig deep into the origins of this festive favorite, and finally have an interesting fact to share around the Christmas table.


So, dear reader, prepare to sip from the fountain of knowledge, to journey through centuries of holiday cheers, to discover... wait for it... the history of eggnog. You'll not only find out why it's called eggnog but also get to meet some historical figures who were just as fond of the drink as you are.


Ready? Good! Now, stop daydreaming, and let's get started! I'll wait for you to finish that swig of holiday liqueur. . . Okay, now, take a deep breath, and let's dive into the frothy, mysterious, pre-refrigeration world of nog.


A Frothy Affair with History: The Origins of Eggnog

Picture this: it's a nippy 13th-century evening in Britain. A chap named Nigel (or something equally British) is sitting by a fireplace, nursing a wooden cup of something creamy, frothy, and oh-so-delicious. Spoiler alert: Nigel is sipping some posset, the earliest incarnation of eggnog. Yes, you heard it right! Our beloved eggnog was born across the pond, in the merry old land of England. While the recipe for eggnog is British, the first written usage of the term is purely American. In a poem about drinking all day, Jonathan Boucher, a clergyman from Maryland receives the credit for being the first to use the word in writing.


Initially, posset was a winter beverage for the British upper class, as eggs and milk were luxury commodities back then. Over time, as it journeyed across the Atlantic to the American colonies, it was embraced by everyone. America, with its vast farms, had plenty of chickens and cows, so the key ingredients of eggnog were readily available. It soon became a staple during the holiday season, and, well, the rest is history.


By the way, if you're craving more fascinating tales about eggnog and its roots, be sure to check out LMLTU's holiday special episode where you can hear some more facts and find out if any of us actually enjoy the idea of drinking heavy cream and uncooked egg yolks. We promise it's more entertaining than listening to Nigel's ponderings about the merits of women in lakes distributing swords as a method of governance.


Decoding the 'Nog' in Eggnog: A Linguistic Adventure

Now, let’s explore some etymology, the study of word origins. What's in a name, you ask? In the case of eggnog, quite a bit. The 'egg' part is straightforward - it’s a key ingredient. But the 'nog'? Not so obvious.


There are a few main theories as to why eggnog is called eggnog. Our favorite is that the word 'nog' is believed to have originated from 'noggin', a term used in the 17th century to refer to a small, carved wooden mug used to serve alcohol. So, it's possible that 'nog' in 'eggnog' was derived from this term, implying a drink served in a noggin. A noggin of egg, if you will.


Another theory posits that 'nog' came from nog, a strong ale that was often served in noggins. In the time of possets, the alcohol in the strong beer was enough to curdle the cream and eggs (apparently that was a desired effect). Yet another theory suggests the beverage's name is just a fun portmanteau of 'Egg and grog' (grog being a slang term for rum). Over time the two words might have been abbreviated to 'eggnog'. Linguistic adventure, indeed!


We've explored the source of 'nog' in eggnog, but the journey is far from over! Stick around for some amazing tales about eggnog's appearances throughout history.


A Merry Toast to History: Iconic Moments with Eggnog

First, our brief history will take you to 18th-century America, where we can hobnob with George Washington himself. As you may know, the man wasn't just the first U.S. president; he was also a connoisseur of good food and drinks. It was well known that he loved ice cream, but what you may not know is he also had his own recipe for eggnog. It seems the Founding Father not only had a bit of a sweet tooth, but he enjoyed his booze as well. His eggnog recipe includes four types of alcohol: rye whiskey, brandy, rum, and sherry! If you ever try it, remember to age it for several days to get the authentic taste. George certainly knew how to throw a party!


Speaking of parties, let's talk about one that took a major detour at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point in 1826. It just so happened that Jefferson Davis, the future president of the Confederate States, was a student at the Academy when a massive brawl erupted, now famously known as the Eggnog Riot or Grog Mutiny.

Here's what went down: The Superintendent at the time, Colonel Sylvanus Thayer, was known for his abstinence from alcohol. So, he decided to make West Point a dry campus for the Christmastime celebration that year. However, the cadets drew a firm line when it came to being served non-alcoholic eggnog. As you can guess, rigid military commanders and a group of young, intoxicated cadets don't exactly make for a harmonious mix, and it wasn't long before the festivities turned into a full-blown conflict.

The old Mess Hall at West Point, one of the historic setting of the Eggnog Riots, where cadets clashed during a Christmas celebration in a spirited incident of unrest.
The old Mess Hall at West Point. National Archives https://catalog.archives.gov/id/526494

The riot resulted in significant property damage, leading to 20 court-martials and even expulsions. It's a remarkable example of just how seriously people can take their eggnog.


The Global Love Affair with Eggnog: Variations and Adaptations

Eggnog’s notoriety is not limited to England and America. This creamy, frothy delight has inspired numerous adaptations around the globe. Let's embark on a quick tour.


Our first stop is Mexico, where you'll find Rompope. Similar to eggnog, it's flavored with vanilla and rum. Next, we jet off to Puerto Rico to sample Coquito, often called Puerto Rican Eggnog. It's a spin on the classic, that uses coconut milk, coconut cream, and a splash of rum for good measure.


Finally, let's sail to the Caribbean, where you can sip on the drink that may have started it all. The potent and spicy concoction from Jamaica called Grog. Trust me, one sip of these and you'll feel like you're on a sun-drenched beach, even in the middle of winter.


From one corner of the world to another, it's clear that the love for eggnog or eggnog-like drinks is universal. It's the type of drink that unites people across continents in shared festive cheer. Just as eggnog has spread and adapted around the globe, other foods have their own fascinating global histories. Take olives, for instance, which have their own storied past.


The Raw Egg Controversy: To Use or Not to Use

If there's one topic that could divide the eggnog-loving community, it's this: the debate over raw eggs. Traditionalists might argue that eggnog just isn't the same without them. But health-conscious folks may not be thrilled about the risks associated with consuming raw eggs.


In truth, the risk of getting sick from raw eggs is relatively low, but it's not zero. Thankfully, there are a few alternatives that keep everyone happy (and healthy). First, you could use pasteurized eggs. They've been heat-treated to kill bacteria, but still whip up nice and frothy for your eggnog.


Alternatively, you could cook your eggnog in a process similar to making custard. It's a little more labor-intensive, but it ensures the eggs are safe to consume. And for those who prefer to skip the eggs altogether, there are numerous egg-free recipes that make use of everything from vanilla pudding to almond milk, and coconut cream for that creamy, rich texture.


Toasting to a Time-Honored Tradition: The Unforgettable Eggnog

Well, folks, we've sipped our way through the frothy layers of history, traveled from English taverns to American colonies, deciphered linguistic puzzles, and witnessed some egg-stravagant global variations. It's been a wild, creamy, and occasionally boozy ride through the world of eggnog.


In this journey, we've discovered that eggnog is more than just a holiday drink; it's a testament to human ingenuity, a symbol of festive cheer that transcends boundaries. Whether it's the traditional recipe handed down through generations or a creative modern adaptation, eggnog holds a special place in our hearts (and holiday menus).


But the eggnog story doesn't end here. Perhaps you've got a family recipe with a secret ingredient, or you've heard an eggnog tale that needs to be told. So, let's keep this conversation flowing. Head on over to the Listener Look-ups page and share your queries or contributions. Who knows, your eggnog story might just be the start of our next adventure!


Now, if you'll excuse me, all this talk about eggnog has left me parched. I think it's high time I fetched myself a glass of that frothy, festive goodness. Care to join me? After all, it's always eggnog o'clock somewhere!

Comments


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page